The key ideas
The Person and the Situation: Perspectives of Social Psychology
Why do kind people walk past someone who asks for help? Two renowned social psychologists gathered the classic experiments of their field and showed how much we overestimate character and underestimate circumstances. The book teaches you to see the situation behind an action and to change behavior with small, precise steps instead of loud appeals.
Who it is for
For anyone who often judges people by a single act and wants to be wrong less often. And for anyone trying to change their own habits or someone else’s and wondering why persuasion doesn’t work.
Social psychology rivals philosophy in its ability to teach people that they do not truly understand the nature of the world.
Preachers running late
Princeton, a theological seminary. Students are asked to prepare a short sermon, and some of them are given the parable of the Good Samaritan. On the way to the next building, each of them passes a man slumped in a doorway, coughing and groaning. In 1973 psychologists Darley and Batson were testing who would stop to help. It turned out to depend hardly at all on what a student’s faith rested on. Something else decided it: whether the student had been told he was already late. Of those who had time to spare, 63 percent helped. Of those running late, only 10 percent.
Lee Ross of Stanford and Richard Nisbett of Michigan gathered dozens of experiments like this into The Person and the Situation. Their main conclusion: we overestimate a person’s character and underestimate the situation that person is in. Almost everyone makes this mistake, from students to professional psychologists.
The mistake is costly. We pin labels on people, predict their actions wrongly and waste effort on changes that don’t work. What follows are four lessons from the book on how to see people more accurately.
The quizmaster always seems to know more
Ross and his colleagues set up a simple game. Participants played in pairs, and drawing lots decided which of the two asked the questions: one made up ten hard questions, the other answered them aloud. The quizmaster naturally asked about things he knew himself, for instance, the name of the fragrant substance from whales that is used as a base for perfume. He could simply avoid showing the gaps in his own knowledge, while the contestant had no such protection. Everyone could see that the roles had been handed out by lot. And still both the players and the observers rated the quizmasters as far more knowledgeable.
The authors call this tendency the fundamental attribution error. Attribution means explaining causes. We see the cause of an action in a person’s character and fail to notice the pressure of circumstances. The person moves and catches the eye, while the situation stays in the background, unnoticed.
The data the authors gathered show that character traits predict behavior only weakly. The link between how honest or sociable a person is in one situation and in another is usually around 0.1 or 0.2 on a scale from zero to one. Yet people are sure it’s close to 0.8.
The authors don’t claim that character doesn’t exist. The world around us really does seem predictable, but that’s because we keep seeing people in the same roles. But in a new situation, a forecast based on character often lets us down. One of the authors once decided that a colleague gave high grades to be popular with students. Then he taught the same course himself, got an unusually strong group and gave high grades too.
So when you see someone do something strange, ask yourself what circumstances would make it ordinary.
About the author
Lee Ross was a professor of psychology at Stanford University, and Richard Nisbett was a professor of psychology at the University of Michigan. Ross introduced the concept of the fundamental attribution error, and their joint work on how people draw conclusions about one another became a classic of social psychology.
All books by this author: Lee Ross, Richard E. Nisbett
The Person and the Situation: Perspectives of Social Psychology Quiz
Terms from the book
- Dartmouth
- Stanford
- Princeton
- Darley
- Batson
- Fundamental attribution error: Lee Ross’s term (1977): the tendency to explain actions by character traits and to underestimate the influence of circumstances. Attribution means explaining causes.
- Lewin: Kurt Lewin, a psychologist who came to the United States from Germany in the mid-1930s. He is considered one of the founders of social psychology and came up with the ideas of channel factors and tension systems.
- Channel factors: Kurt Lewin’s concept: small but decisive details of a setting that open the way from intention to action or block it. For example, a concrete plan or a map.
- False consensus effect: Described by Ross and colleagues in 1977: people think their own choice is more common than it really is and explain the opposite choice by quirks of character.
- Cambridge-Somerville: A program to help at-risk boys in the suburbs of Boston, started in 1935 by Richard Clarke Cabot. Its participants were compared with a control group for another 40 years.
- Tension systems: Kurt Lewin’s idea: the behavior of a person or a group rests on a balance of forces, some pushing toward change and others holding it back. You can change it by strengthening the first or weakening the second.
Similar books
- The Politician: A Companion to Niccolò Machiavelli’s The Prince, Nick Machiavelli
- The Power of Myth, Joseph Campbell
- The Psychology of Interpersonal Behaviour, Michael Argyle
- The Revolution of Hope: Toward a Humanized Technology, Erich Fromm
- The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion, Jonathan Haidt
- The Sixth Extinction: An Unnatural History, Elizabeth Kolbert
- The Social Climber's Bible: A Book of Manners, Practical Tips, and Spiritual Advice for the Upwardly Mobile, Dirk Wittenborn, Jazz Johnson
- The Uninhabitable Earth: Life After Warming, David Wallace-Wells
- The Personal MBA: Master the Art of Business, Josh Kaufman
- The Phoenix Project, Gene Kim, Kevin Behr, George Spafford

