Book quiz
Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking Quiz
Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for ThinkingDaniel C. DennettHow do you object in a way that makes the other person first agree with your summary of their view? Why does the phrase “love is just a word” sound wise while saying almost nothing? The philosopher Daniel Dennett gathered the thinking tools he used all his life and applied them to hard questions about consciousness…
Question 1 of 5
A colleague proposes a plan you think is weak. Where do Rapoport's rules say to start?
Show the answer
Right answer: Restate their position fairly
First restate the position so well that the other person agrees, then name what you share and what you learned, and only then object. Someone who feels understood is more likely to hear criticism.
Question 2 of 5
A friend judges a whole music genre by its two silliest songs. What would Dennett advise?
Show the answer
Right answer: Judge the genre by its best albums
Sturgeon's law: every field has weak work, and it says little about the field. Argue with the best examples and the strongest supporters.
Question 3 of 5
An article says: "Surely no one would dispute that..." What does Dennett advise?
Show the answer
Right answer: Reread that spot especially carefully
An author may put "surely" right where they're unsure and hope the reader will nod along. Not always, but it's a good reason to stop.
Question 4 of 5
Why does a line like "Love is just a word" sound deep?
Show the answer
Right answer: It's undeniable on one reading and weighty on another
Dennett calls this a deepity. About the word, the line is true but trivial; about love itself, it sounds powerful but proves nothing.
Question 5 of 5
Following Hofstadter, what does Dennett advise doing with a thought experiment?
Show the answer
Right answer: Change its details and see whether the intuition survives
An intuition pump works like a device with knobs. Turn a knob and check: a good story helps you grasp an idea, but it can also quietly push you toward a conclusion.
Want all of the book's key ideas? Read or listen to its retelling in Livria.
