Book quiz
Instincts of the Herd in Peace and War Quiz
Instincts of the Herd in Peace and WarWilfred TrotterWhy does a person argue heatedly about taxes and war when he has never studied them, and why is it easier to keep quiet with everyone else than to say your own view? The English surgeon Wilfred Trotter explained this by the herd instinct, which works in each of us, even when we are alone with ourselves. You will…
Question 1 of 5
Everyone in the group praises a film you didn't like, and saying so feels uncomfortable. What does Trotter suggest asking yourself?
Show the answer
Right answer: Am I afraid of being wrong, or of standing apart?
Trotter separates two fears: being wrong and being cut off from your own people. The discomfort often comes from the second, an ancient herd mechanism.
Question 2 of 5
A piece of news seems undeniable to you, since everyone you know has already repeated it. What does the book suggest checking?
Show the answer
Right answer: What convinced you: arguments or how many agree
According to Trotter, the bigger the herd behind a claim, the easier it is to believe. So it matters to separate the arguments from the number who agree.
Question 3 of 5
A friend asks to discuss a firm opinion of yours, and the very idea of doubting it feels improper. What does this mean, according to Trotter?
Show the answer
Right answer: The opinion was most likely suggested to you
Trotter's touchstone: truths won through experience we hold calmly, while a strong reluctance to doubt gives away a belief without grounds.
Question 4 of 5
You like a candidate: he's simple like us and rides a bicycle. What does the book advise?
Show the answer
Right answer: Separate "one of us" from what he can actually do
Trotter explains that resembling us helps a leader lead the herd, but says nothing about his abilities.
Question 5 of 5
You hold a heated opinion on a controversial topic, and your reasoning seems tidy. How does Trotter suggest testing yourself?
Show the answer
Right answer: Make a prediction and check it against events
Bias can't be seen from the inside, and tidy reasoning proves nothing. Trotter advises testing conclusions by prediction.
Want all of the book's key ideas? Read or listen to its retelling in Livria.
